Why Highlighting Choices Beats Empty Praise in the Classroom
Praise has an important place in education, but there is another approach that can make a real difference to children's learning and development. Teaching children to recognise when they are making good choices and when they are making poor choices.
In schools and early years settings, teachers and practitioners have an important responsibility to help children understand their behaviour, develop independence and learn how their actions affect others.
Instead of simply telling a child that they have done something good or bad, we can encourage them to understand WHY their choice was positive or negative.
This small change in language can have a powerful impact on children's confidence, emotional development and ability to make decisions independently.
Why Constant Praise Isn't Always Enough
Children naturally enjoy receiving praise and positive attention from adults. Hearing 'Well done' can make them feel happy and encouraged.
However, children who constantly receive praise without understanding what they have actually done well might begin to depend on adult approval.
For example, imagine a child helping another child tidy away their toys. Instead of simply saying, 'Well done! You're such a good girl!', a teacher could say, 'You made a really good choice by helping your friend tidy away. You were being kind and helpful.'
The second response explains WHY the behaviour was positive and that helps children recognise their own actions and understand what makes a choice helpful, thoughtful and respectful.
The aim is not to stop praising children but to make our language more meaningful and help children develop an understanding of their behaviour.
Teaching Children the Difference Between Good and Poor Choices
One of the most important lessons children can learn is that their choices have consequences. Every day, children make decisions about sharing, listening, taking turns, following instructions and treating others with kindness.
Teachers can use these everyday situations to introduce the language of choices.
For example:
- 'You made a good choice by sharing your toys.'
- 'You made a good choice by using kind words.'
- 'That wasn't a safe choice because you were running indoors.'
- 'You made an unkind choice when you pushed your friend. How could you make things better?'
This approach helps children understand that their behaviour is something they can change.
It is also important to remember that a child is never a bad child because they have made a poor choice. Children are still learning, and mistakes provide valuable opportunities for teaching.
Why We Should Focus on Behaviour Rather Than Labelling Children
There is a big difference between telling a child:
'You are naughty.'
And saying:
'That was not a good choice.'
When we label children as naughty, they may begin to associate their identity with negative behaviour. Instead, focusing on the action separates the child from the behaviour. A child needs to understand that making a poor choice does not make them a bad person. They can apologise, reflect, learn and try again. This is an important part of positive behaviour management and supporting children's emotional well-being.
How Good Choice Language Builds Independence
One of the main aims of education is to help children become independent thinkers.
We want children to make positive decisions because they understand why those decisions matter, not simply because an adult is watching.
When teachers regularly use language such as 'What choice could you make?' or 'How do you think that made your friend feel?', children are encouraged to stop and think.
Over time, they can begin to recognise situations where they need to make a different decision.
This supports:
- Independence and self-confidence.
- Personal responsibility.
- Problem-solving skills.
- Positive relationships.
- Self-regulation.
- Understanding other people's feelings.
These are important life skills that children will continue to use as they grow.
Teaching Children to Learn From Their Mistakes
Children will make mistakes. It is a normal and necessary part of growing up. When a child makes a poor choice, our response should not simply be to tell them off. Instead, we should help them understand what happened and how they could respond differently next time.
For example, if a child takes a toy from another child, we could ask:
'What happened?'
'How do you think your friend felt?'
'What could you do differently next time?'
This encourages reflection rather than shame and also gives children the opportunity to develop empathy and understand that their actions can affect other people.
Practical Positive Behaviour Strategies for Teachers
Here are some simple ways teachers and early years practitioners can introduce good choice language into everyday routines.
During play:
'You made a good choice by inviting your friend to play.'
During disagreements:
'What could you do to solve this problem without hurting anyone?'
During group activities:
'You waited patiently for your turn. That was a thoughtful choice.'
During transitions:
'You chose to walk safely inside. That helps keep everyone safe.'
When a child struggles:
'You are finding this difficult right now. Let's think about a better choice together.'
When a child makes a mistake:
'That choice wasn't helpful, but you can learn from it and try again.'
These small changes can help create a positive classroom environment where children feel supported, respected and understood.
Introducing a Good Choices and Poor Choices Spin the Wheel Activity
Children learn particularly well through play, discussion and practical activities.
A fantastic way to introduce the concept of making positive choices is through a Good Choices and Poor Choices Spin the Wheel activity.
Teachers can use the wheel during circle time, small-group activities or personal, social and emotional development sessions.
Children spin the wheel and discuss the situation they land on.
For example:
- Sharing toys with a friend.
- Pushing someone when they are upset.
- Waiting patiently for a turn.
- Taking something without asking.
- Helping someone who is struggling.
- Using kind words.
- Running inside the classroom.
- Saying sorry after hurting someone's feelings.
After each spin, encourage children to think about the situation.
Ask questions such as:
- Is this a good choice or a poor choice?
- How might this make another person feel?
- What could happen because of this choice?
- What could we do differently?
- How can we make things better?
The purpose is not to embarrass children or make them feel bad. It is to create a safe and enjoyable opportunity to learn about behaviour, kindness, responsibility and respect.
Should Teachers Stop Praising Children?
Absolutely not! Children need encouragement, recognition and positive relationships with the adults around them.
Praise can be very valuable when it is genuine, specific and meaningful. The important thing is to move beyond automatic praise and help children understand the reasons behind their actions.
Instead of only saying 'Well done', we can say: 'I noticed you kept trying even when it was difficult.'
- 'You made a thoughtful decision'
- 'You recognised that your friend needed help.'
- 'You should feel proud of the effort you put into that.'
This encourages children to recognise their own progress rather than always waiting for an adult to tell them they have done well.
Helping Children Make Better Choices Every Day
As teachers, parents and early years practitioners, we have an opportunity to shape how children understand themselves and the world around them.
Our words matter. Instead of simply telling children they are good or bad, we should help them understand that their choices and actions have an impact.
We should encourage children to think, reflect, take responsibility and learn from their mistakes. A child who understands WHY sharing is kind, WHY listening matters and WHY hurting someone is not acceptable is developing skills that go far beyond the classroom.
The message we should be teaching is simple:
You are not a good or bad child. You are a child who is learning every day. You will make good choices, you will sometimes make poor choices, but every day gives you another opportunity to learn, grow and make a better decision.
And perhaps that is one of the most important lessons we can teach.
Play Now: Good Choices & Bad Choices Spin The Wheel Activity